If you live in England – wherever you live in England – there could soon be badger culling in countryside near to you, if the government proceeds with plans on which it is currently consulting. The consultation is open until 15th April, and anyone can respond. Links are provided below to ZSL’s responses, which are based on careful evaluation of scientific evidence.
In 2017 nearly 20,000 badgers were killed by farming groups hoping to protect their cattle from bovine tuberculosis (TB). The proposed policy changes would greatly increase that number. Badgers can indeed pass TB to cattle, although scientists estimate that only about 6% of TB-affected herds acquire infection this way, with the other 94% infected by other cattle herds. Killing badgers lowers badger numbers, but it also causes surviving badgers to range more widely, so that they encounter other badgers and cattle over wider areas. In certain circumstances, these changes can mean that badger culling increases cattle TB rather than reducing it.
In 2017, when badger culling covered 8,555 sq km (an area twice the size of Somerset), there was still no firm evidence that the approach was reducing cattle TB, with infection not significantly different between culled and unculled areas, and no sign of decline in the national epidemic. Nevertheless, the vision remains to expand culling across entire counties where the TB risk to cattle is highest.
The above map shows cattle TB risk for counties in England. The counties shaded in darker blue represent England’s high risk area, and there is a vision to cull this entire area. Light blue “edge” counties are also eligible for large-scale culls. Cattle TB risk is low in the counties shaded white, but if the government’s plans go forward these would become eligible for small-scale culls where cattle TB is confirmed. Most low-risk counties have experienced sporadic TB incidents in the past three years so culls could be scattered across the entire area. Risk map taken from here.
The first consultation, which is available here, describes plans to turn this vision into a reality. Under current rules, Natural England, the organisation responsible for protecting badgers, is allowed to grant up to 10 new cull licences each year (last year’s new areas covered 4,752 sq km, that’s twice the size of Cheshire). Defra proposes removing this cap. This means that, in principle, the high-risk counties could be culled in their entirety this year, creating a massive cull zone stretching unbroken from Lands End to the Peak District. This is a move which Natural England itself noted “has not previously been sanctioned for any protected native mammal species in modern times”.
ZSL opposes this planned policy change. In our consultation response, which you can read here, we explain that such a massive expansion of badger culling would:
- Compromise analyses of whether badger culling is helping to control cattle TB
- Undermine an ongoing scientific review of TB policy
- Preclude using and evaluating promising alternatives, such as badger vaccination
- Risk a major environmental impact, not just on England’s farmland ecosystems, but also on the United Kingdom’s efforts to promote coexistence of people and wildlife internationally.
The second consultation, which is available here, proposes extending badger culling beyond the areas where cattle TB is a persistent problem, to the low-risk area where herd infections are rare and sporadic. Rather than proposing more large-scale culls for these areas, the government plans localised culls focused on specific TB-affected farms.
ZSL opposes this plan to introduce localised badger culling. In our consultation response, which you can read here, we caution that:
- Small-scale badger culling has been repeatedly shown to increase cattle TB rather than reducing it, so this approach risks spreading TB to additional farms in the low risk area
- Badger vaccination would be a much more appropriate way to reduce the risk of bought-in cattle introducing TB to local wildlife
- Pursuing culling outside the framework of the Protection of Badgers Act, as the government suggests, risks sending a message that it tolerates unlicensed killing of protected species.
Responding to public consultations is important. Consultations are not votes, and often policies go forward even if only a minority of respondents support them. But consultations do provide an important opportunity to comment on proposed changes to government policy, and they can lead governments to change their plans. If you would like to respond, you can follow these links to access the two consultations – do read the consultation documents provided there before responding.
- Bovine TB: Consultation on revised guidance for licensing badger control areas
- Bovine TB: consultation on proposals to introduce licensed badger control to prevent the spread of bovine tuberculosis in the Low Risk Area (England)
You can also follow these links to see ZSL’s responses:
Select a blog
Our people are our greatest asset and we realise our vision for a world where wildlife thrives through their ideas, skills and passion. An inspired, informed and empowered community of people work, study and volunteer together at ZSL.
At ZSL, a key area of our work is the employment of Nature-based Solutions – an approach which both adapt to and mitigates the impacts of climate change. These Solutions, which include habitat protection and restoration, are low-cost yet high-impact, and provide multiple benefits to people and wildlife. We ensure that biodiversity recovery is at the heart of nature-based solutions.
A blog for lovers of ZSL London Zoo, bringing you extraordinary animal facts and exclusive access to the world's oldest scientific zoo.
Do you love wildlife? Discover more about our amazing animals at the UK's biggest zoo!
We're working around the world to conserve animals and their habitats, find out more about our latest achievements.
From the field to the lab, catch up with the scientists on the cutting edge of conservation biology at ZSL’s Institute of Zoology.
A day in Discovery and Learning at ZSL is never dull! The team tell us all about the exciting sessions for school children, as well as work further afield.
Every month, one of the pieces held in ZSL’s Library and at ZSL Whipsnade Zoo will feature here as Artefact of the Month.
Read testimonials from our Members and extracts from ZSL's award winning members' magazine, Wild About.
ZSL works across Asia, from the famous national parks of Nepal to marine protected areas in the Philippines. Read the latest updates on our conservation.
An Open Access journal for research at the interface of remote sensing, ecology and conservation.